Deficiency Index

Shepherd of the Valley Liberty

Girard, Ohio · CCN 365298

20 surveys since 2011, 3 of them producing a finding at harm level or worse.

Data as of , released by CMS on October 8, 2026. Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog.

Citations on record
64
Surveys
20
Harm or worse
3
Immediate jeopardy
0
The record, 2011–2026
’11’15’20’25’26
No harm recordedHarm or worseNot surveyed
Harm or worse3

Findings where a surveyor recorded actual harm to a resident.

Beyond CMS’s monthly file15/20

Older surveys no longer in CMS’s monthly file or on Care Compare. They are shown here.

The facility

Certified beds
79
Ownership
Non profit - Church related
Chain
Independent
County
Trumbull
Medicare-certified since
1974

CMS ratings

Overall
3
Health inspection
3
Staffing
4
Quality measures
3

CMS’s own Five-Star ratings.

Compared with similar facilities

Since 2021, this facility recorded more weighted findings than most of its peer group.

Weighted by harm level, against 41 not-for-profit facilities of 66–99 beds in Ohio.

Last survey on record

Mar 23, 2026

231 days ago.

Counts surveys with at least one finding. A clean survey leaves no record here, so the real gap may be shorter.

Staffing

MeasureThis facilityPeer median
Nurse hours per resident day4.344.23
Registered-nurse hours per resident day1.41—
Annual nurse turnover50.6%46.9%

As reported by the facility to CMS, beside the peer-group median.

Enforcement

No fines, payment denials or special-focus designation on the current CMS record.

Severity of recent findings

Citations by CMS scope and severity. Rows are harm level, columns are how widespread the finding was.
SeverityIsolatedPatternWidespread
Immediate jeopardyJ—K—L—
Actual harmG15.6%H—I—
No harm, potential for more than minimalD738.9%E527.8%F527.8%
No harm, potential for minimalA—B—C—
CMS’s current file: 18 of the 64 citations on record.

Most frequently cited here

In CMS’s current monthly file.

  • F6892×

    Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.

  • F5501×

    Honor the resident's right to a dignified existence, self-determination, communication, and to exercise his or her rights.

  • F5801×

    Immediately tell the resident, the resident's doctor, and a family member of situations (injury/decline/room, etc.) that affect the resident.

  • F6021×

    Protect each resident from the wrongful use of the resident's belongings or money.

  • F6071×

    Develop and implement policies and procedures to prevent abuse, neglect, and theft.

In the surveyor’s words

From the most serious findings on record at Shepherd of the Valley Liberty, in the surveyor’s own words.

  • Actual harm, isolatedF689Oct 5, 2023

    Based on observation, record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed prevent a fall with injury for Resident #20. Actual Harm occurred on 07/13/23 when Resident #20 who required extensive assistance of one person for bed mobility, did not have fall prevention interventions in place, fell from bed and sustained large left periorbital and front scalp hematomas (an injury that causes blood to collect and pull under the skin) and a fracture involving the left orbital roof extending into the left frontal sinus. This affected one resident (#20) of three residents reviewed for falls. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF812Sep 22, 2025

    Based on observation, interview and record review, the facility did not ensure food was stored, prepared and served in accordance with professional standards for food safety. This had the potential to affect 54 residents who received meals from the kitchen. The facility identified seven residents (Resident #19, #6, #8, #33, #70, #71 and #1) who received nothing by mouth (NPO). The facility census was 61. Findings Include:Observation on 09/15/25 at 9:54 A.M. of the dry food storage room in the main kitchen revealed the following food items were not dated with the date received: four one-gallon tubs of mayonnaise, one one-gallon Caesar salad dressing tub, one one-gallon Thousand Island dressing tub, two seven-pound five-ounce cans of jellied cranberry sauce, two six-pound cans of diced… […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF835Sep 22, 2025

    Based on record review and interview, the facility administration failed to ensure an effective system was in place to maintain current cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) certification for the licensed nurses for the highest practicable well being of all residents. This had the potential to affect all 61 residents residing in the facility. Findings include:Review of personnel files on [DATE] at 2:39 P.M. with Human Resources Director (HRD) #742 revealed Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) #694's CPR (cardiopulmonary resuscitation) certification expired 03/2025 and was renewed on [DATE]. LPN #696's CPR certification expired [DATE] and was renewed on [DATE]. LPN #684's CPR certification expired 02/2025 and was renewed on [DATE]. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF921May 21, 2025

    Based on observation, interview and record review the facility failed to maintain a clean environment, including mechanical lifts. This affected Resident #3 and had the potential to affect all 65 residents residing in the facility. Findings include: On 05/07/25 between 9:30 A.M. and 10:30 A.M. an initial tour of the building was conducted with the Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON) #112. Resident #3's room was noted to have a dirty floor with visible crumbs and a visible dust buildup behind the door. The toilet in Resident #3's room was noted to have a yellow and streaks around the outer bowl of the toilet. There was also a brown spot on the wall between the toilet and the sink that appeared to be dried feces. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF868Jul 29, 2021

    Based on record review, staff interview, and review of facility policy the facility failed to ensure they met quarterly for the Quality Assurance and Performance Improvement (QAPI) committee and failed to have the Medical Director in attendance. This had the potential to affect all 55 residents currently residing in the facility. Findings include: Review of the QAPI meeting attendance sign in sheets from 07/29/20 through 07/29/2021 revealed the facility only met on 04/29/21 and 07/21/21. There was no Medical Director signature on the 04/29/21 minutes. Interview on 07/29/21 at 4:15 P.M. with the Director of Clinical Services (DCS) #900 verified the facility only met on 04/29/21 and 07/21/21 and she stated she believed due to the COVID-19 pandemic they did not have to meet. […]

Read 22 findings in full →The most serious and the most recent: 22 of 64 on record.

Every survey on record

FindingsAt actual harm or above

  • Mar 23, 2026Complaint1 finding
  • Sep 22, 2025Standard and complaint7 findings
  • May 21, 2025Complaint1 finding
  • Oct 5, 2023Standard7 findings · 1 harm
  • Dec 9, 2021Complaint1 finding
  • Jul 29, 2021Standard3 findings
  • Apr 22, 2021Complaint2 findings
  • Mar 21, 2019Standard7 findings
Show the 12 earlier surveys
  • Mar 8, 2018Complaint1 finding
  • Dec 22, 2016Standard4 findings
  • Sep 21, 2016Complaint1 finding
  • Sep 15, 2016Complaint2 findings
  • Jan 7, 2016Complaint1 finding
  • Oct 13, 2015Standard1 finding
  • Sep 24, 2015Complaint1 finding
  • Jul 17, 2014Standard6 findings
  • Mar 5, 2014Complaint1 finding · 1 harm
  • Apr 12, 2013—4 findings
  • Mar 22, 2012—2 findings
  • Jan 21, 2011—11 findings · 1 harm

Surveys that found no deficiencies are not in CMS’s files and do not appear here.

Comparable facilities

The nearest facilities to this one in the same peer group, by weighted findings.

Deficiency Index is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by CMS, Medicare, or any government agency. About this data · Report a correction