Deficiency Index

Mcgivney Health Care Center

Carmel, Indiana · CCN 155855

17 surveys since 2017. The first finding at harm level was recorded in 2023.

Data as of , released by CMS on October 8, 2026. Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog.

Citations on record
115
Surveys
17
Harm or worse
1
Immediate jeopardy
0
The record, 2017–2026
’17’20’25’26
No harm recordedHarm or worseNot surveyed
Harm or worse1

Findings where a surveyor recorded actual harm to a resident.

Beyond CMS’s monthly file14/17

Older surveys no longer in CMS’s monthly file or on Care Compare. They are shown here.

The facility

Certified beds
37
Ownership
Non profit - Corporation
Chain
WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
County
Hamilton
Medicare-certified since
2017

CMS ratings

Overall
2
Health inspection
3
Staffing
1
Quality measures
3

CMS’s own Five-Star ratings.

Compared with similar facilities

Since 2021, this facility recorded more weighted findings than most of its peer group.

Weighted by harm level, against 26 not-for-profit facilities with fewer than 66 beds in Indiana.

Last survey on record

Aug 26, 2025

440 days ago.

Counts surveys with at least one finding. A clean survey leaves no record here, so the real gap may be shorter.

Staffing

MeasureThis facilityPeer median
Nurse hours per resident day2.914.42
Registered-nurse hours per resident day0.13—
Annual nurse turnover20.0%45.2%

As reported by the facility to CMS, beside the peer-group median.

Enforcement

Fines
$8,189 across 1 penalty
Payment denials
1

Federal civil money penalties and remedies as CMS currently publishes them. Amounts may still be under appeal.

Severity of recent findings

Citations by CMS scope and severity. Rows are harm level, columns are how widespread the finding was.
SeverityIsolatedPatternWidespread
Immediate jeopardyJ—K—L—
Actual harmG12.3%H—I—
No harm, potential for more than minimalD3683.7%E49.3%F24.7%
No harm, potential for minimalA—B—C—
CMS’s current file: 43 of the 115 citations on record.

Most frequently cited here

In CMS’s current monthly file.

  • F6563×

    Develop and implement a complete care plan that meets all the resident's needs, with timetables and actions that can be measured.

  • F8123×

    Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.

  • F9123×

    Provide rooms that are at least 80 square feet per resident in multiple rooms and 100 square feet for single resident rooms.

  • F6442×

    Coordinate assessments with the pre-admission screening and resident review program; and referring for services as needed.

  • F6902×

    Provide appropriate care for residents who are continent or incontinent of bowel/bladder, appropriate catheter care, and appropriate care to prevent urinary tract infections.

In the surveyor’s words

From the most serious findings on record at Mcgivney Health Care Center, in the surveyor’s own words.

  • Actual harm, isolatedF760Sep 22, 2023

    Based on interview and record review, the facility failed to ensure a resident received the correct medication for 1 of 1 resident reviewed for a significant medication error. (Resident 20) Resident 20 required an intensive care stay in the hospital for 5 days. Finding includes: The record for Resident 20 was reviewed on 9/19/23 at 2:01 p.m. Diagnoses included, but were not limited to, dementia with other behavioral disturbance, bradycardia, abnormal weight loss, mood disorder, chronic pain syndrome, and hypertension. A progress note, dated 6/30/23 at 9:25 am, indicated the resident was noted to be lethargic. The skin was cool to touch, he had increased slurring speech, and his speech was garbled. The provider was notified and requested a transfer to the emergency department. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF628Aug 21, 2026

    Based on interview and record review, the facility failed to notify the Ombudsman of residents' transfer and discharges with the reason and destination of the transfer and to provide a guardian/responsible party with the notification of the bed hold policy for 10 of 10 residents reviewed for discharge process. (Resident B, C, D, E, F, G, H, J, K and L)Findings include: An email from the State Long Term Care Ombudsman, dated 8/19/26 at 10:43 a.m., indicated the facility had not reported any acute transfers or discharges since 10/13/25. 1. The clinical record for Resident B was reviewed on 8/18/26 at 10:02 a.m. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF809Sep 22, 2023

    Based on interview and record review, the facility failed to ensure residents were offered bedtime snacks each evening. There was a 15-hour time lapse between the supper meal and breakfast. This deficient practice had the potential to affect 35 of 35 residents who resided in the facility. Finding includes: A dining schedule, provided at entrance, indicated the facility supper time was 5:00 p.m., and breakfast was at 8:00 a.m., which was a 15-hour time lapse between these meals. During an interview, on 9/20/23 at 11:00 a.m., CNA 10 indicated the cook on the evening shift would gather a cart of snacks including peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and crackers. The facility staff did not pass out the snacks although they were available for any resident who wanted them. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF812Sep 22, 2023

    Based on observation, interview and record review, the facility failed to thaw out meat safely and have the sanitizing solution (used to disinfect tables and counters) bucket levels at the recommended range to kill bacteria. This deficient practice had the potential to affect 35 of 35 residents who received food from the kitchen. Findings include: During the kitchen observation, on 9/17/23 at 11:00 a.m., with the Dietary Staff 19 the following were observed: a. The sink contained 2 large plastic bags of frozen chicken. The sink had no cold water in the sink and the chicken was thawing at room temp. b. The red sanitizer bucket was tested three times. Dietary Staff 19 placed a test strip into the bucket and the testing strip did not change colors. […]

  • No harm, potential for more than minimal, widespreadF727Sep 27, 2022

    Based on observation, interview and record review, the facility failed to ensure a Registered Nurse (RN) was on site for 8 hours a day for 60 of 63 days from July 27, 2022 to September 27, 2022. This deficient practice had the potential to effect 34 of 34 residents residing in the facility. Finding includes: During the Entrance Conference, on 09/26/22 at 9:56 a.m., the Executive Director indicated the facility had not had a Director of Nursing since July 2022, when the Director of Nursing was terminated. The facility had a RN but the nurse was injured about two (2) weeks ago and had not been in the facility. The registered nurse was PRN (as needed), not a full time employee. […]

Read 20 findings in full →The most serious and the most recent: 20 of 115 on record.

Every survey on record

FindingsAt actual harm or above

  • Aug 21, 2026Complaint1 finding
  • Aug 26, 2025Standard13 findings
  • Oct 2, 2024Standard5 findings
  • Sep 22, 2023Standard25 findings · 1 harm
  • Nov 14, 2022Complaint1 finding
  • Sep 27, 2022Complaint4 findings
  • Jul 26, 2022Standard12 findings
  • Apr 25, 2022Complaint1 finding
Show the 9 earlier surveys
  • Jun 11, 2021Standard8 findings
  • Jun 10, 2020Complaint3 findings
  • Mar 2, 2020Complaint2 findings
  • Dec 20, 2019Complaint2 findings
  • Jul 31, 2019Complaint2 findings
  • Jun 17, 2019Standard and complaint11 findings
  • Aug 17, 2018Complaint1 finding
  • Jun 14, 2018Standard10 findings
  • Jun 23, 2017Standard14 findings

Surveys that found no deficiencies are not in CMS’s files and do not appear here.

Comparable facilities

The nearest facilities to this one in the same peer group, by weighted findings.

Deficiency Index is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by CMS, Medicare, or any government agency. About this data · Report a correction